Report of the inaugural Religion and Media festival ‘Exploring Belief’
JW3 Centre, Finchley, north London. Tuesday March 27th 2018
Religion Media Centre trustees and advisory board members joined others to organise the inaugural Religion and Media Festival, Exploring Belief, which took place at the JW3 centre in London at the end of March.
A stellar cast of panellists and speakers including James Harding, Mark Thomp son and Frank Cottrell-Boyce addressed why and how religion is reported and portrayed in the media.
More than 100 people attended throughout the day, including academics studying the sociology of religion, theology and media, journalists working in general news and specialising in religion, press officers from faith groups, film makers and people whose working lives involve an engagement with religion in public life and the media.
Broadcaster Roger Bolton suggested that the media in the UK should reflect that 84% of the world͛s population have a religious affiliation, yet broadcasting hours were in decline. Speakers throughout the day analysed whether this was because the media is generally secular and against religion, or because stories about religion couldn’t compete with news from other areas of public life.
James Harding, former editor of the Times and former director of BBC News, said: There’s often an assumption among people of faith that newsrooms are secular if not arrogantly atheist.That’s not been my experience. Many people who don’t believe in God work in news, but there are plenty who do and there any many people for whom their identity, history and life are all bound up with religion, belief and a sense of belonging.
“Religious correspondents are blessed with a beat that really speaks to people – how they live, how they love, how they work, how they die. I am arguing there are better stories out there.”
Mark Thompson, president and CEO of the New York Times and former director-general of the BBC, joined the conference by Skype and said the idea that religion has ceased to be a force in society is manifestly not true:
“Whether reporting Northern Ireland or conservative politics in the USA, I think great journalists are open-minded about everything including faith. In the late 70s and early 80s there was a view that religion shouldnt exist, and very soon wont exist, and is therefore quite an irrelevance. But the central task of journalism, of trying to understand what is happening in your own country and the world, is indissolubly linked with questions of faith.”
Criticism by faith groups that they are misunderstood and misrepresented by a media which is out of touch, was given full vent in a panel debate, chaired by Emily Buchanan.
Miqdaad Versi, assistant secretary-general of the Muslim Council of Britain, has made numerous complaints to newspapers about the coverage of Islam, resulting in 50 corrections in the last 18 months: “Religious coverage seems to be very focused on negativity, this is problematic as polls show that the majority of people in this country find out about Islam through the media. Some of this is pure inaccuracy, but some journalists have a pre-held prejudice.”
Charmaine Noble-Mclean, director of content for Premier Christian Radio, also complained of negativity when reporting Christianity: “When I look at press or mainstream TV, I see corrupt vicars, perverted priests, the church in decline, churches with scandal – that’s what it feels like. We don’t seem to tell the ordinary stories of great Christians who do everyday things.”
The journalists challenged back. Catherine Pepinster, a former editor of the Tablet, said: “Journalists ought to be doing better but some of those who respond to journalists also need to do better. One inquiry took three or four days to get back to me. I would like to know to what extent Muslims are proactive, rather than issuing a correction, helping to keep journalists better informed about Islam.”
And Peter Stanford, a freelance writer, said huge cutbacks in newsroom staff resulted in pressure to do a story faster with fewer resources, and the lack of religious education in schools wasleading to a loss of religious literacy.
An intervention during the debate from Dr Jasjit Singh, of the University of Leeds, stressed the importance of the media speaking to academics and educators with specialist expertise on religion, as going to faith and belief leaders alone won’t give the full picture of religion. This was good news for the Religion Media Centre, as that is exactly our aim.
The festival took place in the middle of the row over Facebook’s use of data, but one of its key executives in the UK, policy manager Dr Erin Marie Saltman, told the gathering that the online space is going through a moral crisis. Facebook is learning from errors and has a responsibility to evolve, she said.
Her work in countering terrorism and violent extremism showed the importance of enabling community voices to be heard: “You see hate-based extremist movements that utilise and cling on to religion for legitimacy, but the internet allows the loudest active people to get attention in a way that they couldn’t before. We need to create an infrastructure that promotes positive voices help community voices to upscale and help bring their voices online.”
One hour was devoted to BBC output and strategy, following a recent review on BBC Religion and Ethics, which concluded that there should be a religion editor in BBC News, a global team of specialist reporters, religious festivals marked on flagship shows and new dramas and documentaries commissioned.
The report author, Mark Friend, said a network of specialists will be created in production areas, to ensure that experts on religion, already working within the BBC, join together to achieve these goals. BBC TV commissioning editor Fatima Salaria said she wanted to make religion and faith feel exciting and relevant. Programmes such as, Muslims Like Us, had prompted people to look at Muslims in a completely different way that they are not the same. Mohit Bakaya, religion commissioner for BBC Radio, said radio broadcasts, downloads and podcasts reached millions of people. “Radio 4’s strategy is to try to understand how faith is shaping and has shaped our world today.”
͞Understanding the audience was another key panel debate. Katie Harrison, director of the Faith Research Centre at Comres, explained that although 53% of the UK have no religion, one quarter of this segment pray, believe in life after death or in angels. Also the population is not static: “Numbers of people identifying as Christian and Muslim will increase across the world, according to projections.”
The golden moment for many was an interview with Frank Cottrell-Boyce, by broadcaster Hannah Scott-Joynt. In a deeply personal contribution, he spoke with immense humour about faith as an important dimension to his work in film making, which “busts you out of the prison of the present”. He had come to recognise his calling as contributing some grace and wonder into the world through his work. With a Catholic heritage, he said, “Judaism is the mother of my faith and the father of my socialism. “The festival closed with a reception for the newly formed Religion Media Centre, which aims to address the issues raised during the day. Chair Michael Wakelin said: “The festival was enriching and challenging, with contributions and audience interventions from top people in the media world and leading thinkers on religion and public life. We hope it will be the first of many. It proved the need for the Religion Media Centre, which seeks to help journalists cover religion through providing context and comment.”